To the op. I owned a 2005 TT 225. I currently have a 2010 S4, 07 GTI and an S2000. First let me compare the TT and GTI which both ran with performance winter tires. The TT was unstoppable. The GTI was safe but no comparison to the TT. I traded the TT with regret for the S4. The S4 ran last winter with winter performance tires. This car was heads and tails better than the TT. In four inches of snow you floor the car it just takes off, it's unbelievable.

I really enjoyed the TT which was lowered as is my S4. You really can't lose on either one as a winter car, however, there is no comparison to the S4, it's that good. When I bought the car I had a 150km ride home in winter with slick conditions riding on summer tires. It was scary to say the least. That was the first and last ride in winter on summer tires, terrible. The difference is night and day.

 

Either car will get you through the Montreal winter. However, the S4 is a better car over all. Bigger, faster and doesn't look like a chicks car. That's my 2 cents.

 

Thanks guys for the opinions, it is almost sure I will get the audi s4 since I will only have one car for winter/summer. I guess maybe when I have 2 cars I will get the TT for fun.

Thanks a bunch seinsmeld13 for the useful comparison.

 

I'll wager anything that you didn't have the exact same tires on both cars!



Fightin' words!